Carano was linked with an NFL player in the past; was married to Kevin Ross, a mixed martial artist, during 2014–2015. She dated Kevin James Feely, a former U.S. Army Ranger, between 2015 and 2018. Her romance with Luke Zocchi, a mixed martial artist, spanned 2018–2020. A previous relationship with Aviator, a production company founder, Josiah Z, is said to have started around 2020.